After 13 years here, I have been increasingly aware that my written Polish is below par and certainly nowhere near good enough to be able to use it in a literary manner. In Polish I cannot write short letters to newspapers nor pithy comments to bloggers who've gone way off course nor lengthy analysis pieces accurately summarising differences between British and Polish society. My non-standard Polish accent makes me a hit with TV and radio editors (I appear a couple of times a month on average commenting on UK events) indeed my accent lends a certain credibility to what I'm saying. But accent cuts no ice with print editors dissecting the written word.
I also feel that I write about the English language better (in particular grammar and syntax) if I can authoritatively refer to Polish equivalents to highlight differences and similarities - which I can't right now.
Why is my written Polish poor? After all, I usually write 20-30 emails in Polish during the course of a working day...
1) Shaky foundations. Polish is, like Latin, a language of declensions and conjugations. I learnt all this stuff like biernik, czasownik, bezokolicznik, przyimek at Polish Saturday school in West London round about the time that Gierek was taking over from Gomułka here in Poland. Consequently what's left of it in my head is a rather confused mixture of half-remembered rules.
2) Literal translation. It annoys me when I see Poles translating into English using Polish word order and directly transposed figures of speech, yet I do exactly the same when trying to get my thoughts (in English) into good Polish.
3) Inadequate vocabulary. In Polish it is considered good form to display your education by spattering your text with literary allusions, metaphors derived from the Classics, clever historical parallels. [In English this is the sign of a tiresome show-off. Below: a foreign intellectual as drawn by Nicholas Bentley, from George Mikes's timeless How To Be An Alien]
It's the foundations that need addressing first. Once I make a mistake in using the wrong case for the object, that mistake then carries on into all the adjectives that follow it. So it's back to basics - the kto/co, kogo/czego, komu/czemu, kogo/co etc need to be learnt by heart (plus the exceptions) rather than just guessed at as at present. Kolin has a good take on this for all you non-Poles out there.
Prefixes to verbs are another problem I have. If phrasal verbs give Poles problems (to send over, to send out, to send in, to send across etc), I have problems with the Polish equivalents - przysłać, przesłać, wysłać or rozesłać?
And quite a few Polish verbs have two infinitive forms! (eg. rozśmieszyć/rozśmieszać.) The latter appears to be a continuous infinitive(?).
And what's the difference between 'zabierz swoje pióra' and 'zabierz twoje piora' (take your pens / take your pens)?
Eventually, my aim is to be able to get some texts published in Polish.
Note: 'Eventually' I have learnt does not mean ewentualnie, which simply means 'or'.
Even if you write to newspapers, can't you write as good as you can (or have someone proofreading it) and let them polish everything up, correct errors, etc.
ReplyDeleteYes, I thought about commenting on Toyah's post, but in spite of lack of language barrier, it appears difficult to put it in words.
Yet, it's not the biggest problem to have an English text translated into decent Polish, when there are plenty of translators for whom Polish is a first language. Things get worse when you try to translate the other way round.
Phrasal verbs: Poles avoid them, but in English it's more complicated than equivalents of Polish prefixes, English phrasals have multiple meanings and the only way to get to grips with them is to learn them by heart.
rozśmieszyć / rozśmieszać are dokonany / niedokonany form - a quite intricate concept, I don't feel up to the task of explaining it so try to unravel it on your own.
Can't you ask your children to do a proofreading - after all for them Polish should be the first language, as opposite to you. There are hundreds of Poles who can do you a favour of correcting a text written by you. Or can't you send it to a newspaper in English and let them do the job? Or aren't Polish journalists capable of such a complicated task?
PS. diSSect or diSect?
Hi Michał,
ReplyDeleteAs a regular reader of your blog, I'm surprised to read that your written Polish skills are not up to par with your written English.
In any case your timing on this post coincides well with my interests - I'm learning Polish from scratch - and recently started blogging about the process. I know other blogs exist that do a much better job of working through some of these grammatical difficulties, but for me most of the point of the exercise is working through the problems, making plenty of mistakes and corrections, and phrasing my own examples. I'm trying to assemble more Polish language links, and aspire to write more of my blog in Polish as my skills increase.
I'm interested in more posts from you on this topic . . . right up my alley these days!
I shamelessly promote my new blog here, with a nod of attribution to those that have come before me :) :
http://borsuknapradze.blogspot.com
Powodzenia!