Thursday, 19 November 2026

Three levels of political discourse

I am indebted to my brother Marek for suggesting to me that I follow Vlad Vexler on YouTube. I have come to consider Vlad one of the most sagacious political philosophers of our time. He rises above mere ideology and tribalism to consider the role of neurodiversity in politics (narcissism, psychopathy, autism spectrum, ADHD etc) and frames the current era as 'post-truth politics'.

A few weeks ago, Vlad Vexler published a talk which I considered fundamentally important. He breaks down levels of political communication into three types: the simplistic, the reasoned and the specialist. The danger for politicians, says Vlad, is using the wrong type when you're trying to explain a complicated issue to an electorate that cannot be expected to possess specialist knowledge of a subject. 

As an example, he played an extract from a discussion he had with Anthony Scaramucci (famously Trump's communications director for 11 days in 2017). Following a discussion about Trump's narcissism, Vlad set out three ways in which one might describe the psychological mechanisms driving Trump's behaviour.

To summarise his argument, they are as follows:

1. Rally level – the immediately intelligible message. Short, emotionally resonant statement that communicates a simple political idea, simply. It requires little prior knowledge, and works in a speech, slogan or brief media appearance.

2. Debate level – the reasoned explanation. A more developed argument incorporating causal relationships, evidence, qualifications and counterarguments. This is appropriate for political interviews, serious discussions and informed commentary.

3. Specialist level – expert analysis of the underlying mechanisms, institutional structures, dependencies and unresolved questions. Suitable for economists, constitutional lawyers, diplomats and policy specialists.

Addressing the Trump question, Vlad gives the following example. Level 1 is to say: "Trump is a bully who craves attention." Level 2 is "Trump needs people to admire him or fear him, and he treats people as instruments for satisfying his own needs." Level 3 is "Trump's sense of self depends on idealised others as a source of self-regulation." 

Everybody can understand Level 1. Level 2 requires a little more thought and attention. But Level 3, which depends on precise use of professional jargon, should be used in expert-to-expert discourse, between specialists who know exactly what each term means. And if you had to read that Level 3 sentence twice, you've understood Vlad's point. Now, Level 3 isn't necessarily truer than Level 1. It is more technically detailed. A good Level 1 explanation can be entirely truthful, just as a sophisticated Level 3 argument can be wrong.

The same can be said of Brexit (I write this post on the eve of UK-EU talks). The Remain campaign relied too heavily on economic forecasts, institutional explanations and warnings about the consequences of leaving – arguments that struggled to compete with the emotional immediacy of the Leave campaign's slogans. 

The problem is that the EU is an extraordinarily complex political and economic construct. Trying to explain the difference between an EU directive and a single-market regulation, or qualified majority voting to people is difficult. Telling people to 'take back control' and 'stop the unelected bureaucrats of Brussels' is easy. [Like, since when has a bureaucrat ever been elected? Bureaucrats are appointed. In Whitehall as in Brussels.]

If you want to win a nationwide referendum – or indeed a presidential election – you need a compelling Level 1 message; Level 2 arguments and Level 3 expertise must underpin it, and not replace it.

Why should politics and economics be simple? Quantum mechanics is extraordinarily complex; physicists themselves disagree about what it tells us about reality. Yet its predictions are incredibly accurate, and technologies based upon it work. Complexity is not a sign of failure.

Many institutions are imperfect, yet serve us vastly better than the alternatives. The EU is one such institution: cumbersome, bureaucratic, often infuriating, but capable of delivering benefits that its individual member states would struggle to achieve alone. Britain out on its own means additional bureaucracy for business, new trade barriers and diminished political influence in the world.

One problem with political debate in times of increasing complexity isn't merely that people disagree about the facts, but that they are trying to communicate at different levels of understanding.

It is necessary to distinguish between simplifying an argument so that it can be understood, and simplifying it so much that it becomes misleading. Much of the trouble with the Leave campaign lay in the latter.

Those of us who want Britain to rejoin the EU recognise that European integration involves trade-offs between sovereignty, prosperity, democratic accountability and international influence. But the more we try to explain those compromises, the greater the risk of losing our audience to someone offering a simple, emotionally satisfying alternative.

The lesson from Vlad Vexler is not that we should dumb down the argument for rejoining the EU. Rather, we need to learn to express it at Level 1 without sacrificing the intellectual integrity of Levels 2 and 3. The challenge for those of us who want Britain back in the EU (and indeed keep Poland in the EU) is to communicate the truth as simply and compellingly as the Leave campaign communicated its falsehoods ten years ago. 

It won't be easy.


This time last year:
AI dreams of the future

This time four years ago:
Winter's on its way

This time nine years ago:
Kolej grójecka by Bogdan Pokropiński

This time 11 years ago:
PIS, thinking wishfully about the village

This time 13 years ago:
An unseasonably warm autumn in Warsaw

This time 14 years ago:
Shedding light on an unused road

This time 15 years ago:
S2-S79 Elka from the air 

This time 16 years ago:
Fish and chips in Warsaw

This time 17 years ago:
Spirit of place – anomalous familiarity moments 

No comments: