Wednesday, 18 November 2026

Monochrome

This morning, while scrolling through my social-media feed, an advert popped up – for the Leica Q3 Monochrom, a Black Friday snip at 25,000 złotys (around £5,000) Usual price, 30,000 złotys (around £6,000). The damned thing doesn't even have a rangefinder and can't take photos in colour – one for poseurs and pseuds.

By removing the colour filter array that digital sensors use to interpret colour, Leica Monochrom cameras deliver exceptionally high native ISOs, significantly reducing image noise in low light, and "a level of pixel-level sharpness that traditional colour sensors cannot match". However, this assumes you don't have a newish version of Photoshop that uses AI to de-noise photos shot at high ISOs. Which I have. And even on a dull day like today, with manually set aperture and shutter and auto ISO, the ISO never approaches levels that would result in blocky pixel artefacts. 

As I set off on my walk today, the day was kind of monochrome, so I decided to present today a set of photos in black and white – shot in colour, but reworked using Photoshop to strip out the colour.

It's certainly a day for black and white.

 Below: looking up the hill towards Chynów station from the bottom end of my lane. Clouds are scudding in from the south-west 

Below: Chynów's ulica Wolska is currently being resurfaced after the modernisation of the water and sewage pipes. The shops and restaurants at the Główna end are all open to cars at the moment.

Below: all the trees are bare. Ul. Główna, Chynów looking north from the junction with ul. Wolska.


Below: looking back along ul. Główna, on the right the health centre, and beyond that Chynów's wooden church. To think that this was once the main Berlin-Moscow road!


Below: ul. Miodowa about to merge with ul. Główna. The road behind me is on the list of roads to be resurfaced, hopefully with asphalt right up to the railway line, and hopefully not before too long.


Below: ul. Grójecka, which acts as the service road running parallel to the DK50 highway as far as the railway line.


Below: electronic road toll gantry over the DK50, T-mobile mobile phone tower to the right, acoustic screen between the road and houses on the other side. Still no news as to whether or not this stretch of road will one day be widened into a full-blown motorway, as the A50 (AOW or Autostradowa Obwodnica Warszawy – Warsaw Motorway Bypass).


Below: signals along the railway line.


Below: nearly home – the first house along my lane. In black and white…


…and in colour. And now the crucial question:


Which image is emotionally the stronger one? And why? Whichever one you choose, I take comfort in knowing that I can take photos in black and white or colour, without paying vastly over the odds just to shoot monochrome.

For photography's first century, black and white was the only way to go, the default mode of recording the world. From the introduction of Kodachrome to the mass market in 1936, colour film slowly began edging black-and-white photography into an art-house niche with its own aesthetic. Colour prints became available in the 1950s and generally affordable in the 1960s; digital photography had largely supplanted film photography by 2010. So my question is – what is monochrome photography for? In Poland, there's a cultural attachment of black-and-white images with death – I see a black-and-white of a politician or celebrity and my first thought is that they have just died. That, rather than "oh, an artsy portrait of so-and-so." Landscapes? Landscapes of death – the scene of some wartime attrocity?

For me, a photograph should capture the qualia memory of having been there. And these generally are strongest on sunny days. The sky should be blue, rather than dark grey. Monochrome photos don't bring back qualia memories of being there; rather they bring back qualia memories of having seen that photo somewhere before, in a book, newspaper or magazine. But they do have a role to play in my search for the sublime aesthetic; I shall be continuing that search.
 
This time two years ago:
How to look at the future

This time three years ago:
First snow, 2023

This time four years ago:
The Algorithm of Fate

This time five years ago:
Non-local consciousness - science and spirituality

This time six years ago:
Fenced in at last

This time eight years ago:
Poznań's Old Market

This time ten years ago:
Brexit, Trump and negative emotions

This time 15 years ago:
Premier Tusk's second exposé

This time 16 years ago:
Into Poland's former Heart of Darkness

This time 17 years ago:
Commuter schadenfreude

No comments: